Travels with Myself and Another, by Martha Gellhorn. Pub 1978

This was a gift from my fellow bookclubber, something to help me get the elusive non-fiction travel book category on our list. Subtitled Five Journeys from Hell, these are not stories to inspire one to go out into the world.

Gellhorn was a journalist and writer for her career and life. A war correspondent in WWII, Korea, Vietnam, and elsewhere, she was not shy about being in difficult locations in the world. As she describes in the introduction to this collection – her only memoir-like writing – she was always nomadic, living in seven countries and travelling to and through more than 40 (including 24 of them more than once). Given her war travels, she is well equipped to recognize true travel hell, and these journey certainly meet that. (She was also married to Hemingway for a while, a fact she tried to downplay for the rest of her life, to avoid that being what she was best known for.)

However, I found with most of these trips, the hell was somewhat self-imposed through lack of planning (or just general disorganization) and research, and a surprising level of naiveté. For example, her trip across Africa in 1962 (the longest story in the book) is full of shocking oversights on her part, from not bringing the correct clothing (she plans to primarily walk through Africa, from Cameroon to Tanzania via Kenya, but brings just a pair of sandals and no hat) to getting dangerously sunburned while swimming.

The stories were also partly incomplete. Gellhorn references her notes and diaries from these trips, but frequently pulls out of the narrative to remind the reader that she’s telling these mostly from memory or that she doesn’t have good notes or a clear memory of an event (so she either glosses it over or skips it all together). In this sense, she is a frustrating storyteller, and I confess to nearly giving up on the book partway through the Africa story, the first part of which has the opposite problem – it is her travel diaries verbatim, with the extreme detail that make people avoid hearing about other people’s travel (a fact Gellhorn acknowledges in her introduction).

However, when Gellhorn moves from talking about how terrible the trips were to the wonderful experiences she had and her insights about societies and cultures, she is amazing. Her reflections on Kenya and Tanzania, as well as her critique of Russia under the Soviet regime and more generally, are well written, perceptive, and prescient.

It’s impossible not to be shocked by the casual racism from Gellhorn throughout. Definitely of her time, her comments are not meanspirited or deliberately degrading but still a surprise from a person who is clearly worldly. As with her travel planning, Gellhorn’s explorations of other cultures – as an upper class, well-funded, white American woman – is often ham-handed, and she doesn’t seem to get why the poor locals in China or Africa don’t want to get to know her or let her know them.

I’m glad I pushed through to the latter half of the book, which is where Gellhorn redeems the stories and writing with more analysis of the societies rather than the details of travel horrors (almost all involving food, toilets, sleeping conditions, and transporation). I’m interested in reading the articles she wrote from these journeys, and perhaps some of her fiction.

Fate: I won’t read this again, so little book library

6 – travel
8 – female
13 – never been
23 – memoir
25 – new author
27 – gift

Leave a Reply

Powered by WordPress.com.

Up ↑