The Cure for Drowning, by Loghan Paylor. Pub 2024

This book was recommended by a friend, who read it after it won the 2026 Canada Reads series. I knew nothing about it other than that, but I picked it up before vacation to read ahead of my next tea date with my friend. I should have asked more questions.

Set in rural Ontario, The Cure for Drowning tells the story of Kit (formerly Kathleen) McNair, starting with their gender transition in 1931 at 10 years old following their death by drowning and folkloric restoration by their mother. Growing into adulthood and chaffing against the expectations of life as a woman, Kit falls in love with the woman next door, runs away without her, and joins the air force at the start of World War II. Passing as a man for the duration of the war (by assuming another man’s identity), Kit returns and is reunited with their lover (and the lover’s child by Kit’s brother). Kit continues to pass for male and the family relocates to Victoria to start their life together.

While this could have been an interesting look at a non-binary person in the mid-20th century, it is instead a hot mess of a story. While seeming to possess strong self-awareness and maturity, Kit is still just a teenager, reacting to small slights with floods of hot tears and storming off to sulk and commune with nature whenever they feel misunderstood. This makes their determination to be their unique self less convincing, as they seem too immature to be making such choices.

I also found the catalyst for Kit’s transition – her drowning and resurrection – to undermine the notion that non-binary identities are a common and natural occurring. Does it require a death experience to transition? Was the “cure for drowning” the loss of gender identity? That Kit is different – a changeling, as her family considers them – is not unexpected, but it might have been more interesting to have her post-death life have more clearly supernatural elements (the vague “I hear voices in the woods” episodes are silly) rather than, or in addition to, their non-binary identity.

There is a recurring story in the family’s lore about a selkie, which seems to be included to reflect identities that are fluid and changeable. However, there is no direct or even oblique connection made between Kit and the legendary selkie. The selkie of the story chooses to move between identities based on their love for a human; this further disrupts any connection to the notion of identity being something one is born with, rather than something one chooses and can change at will, and only when one is a supernatural being.

Even more distracting with were the detail errors that should have been caught at editing. On pages 79 and 80 is the same description of “cicadas droning in the ash trees”. On page 125, Kit refers to a gun in the barn and the nearby bullets; since this turns out to be a shotgun, the reference should have been to shells rather than bullets (a detail Kit, having grown up on the farm, would have known). On page 139, Rebekah suddenly longs for a cigarette; this is the first mention of her smoking, which seems quite out of character for her, but suddenly everyone in the novel is smoking. I gave up tracking these detail errors; suffice to say, they were distracting and unnecessary.

At the point where the three teenagers go their separate ways at the start of the war, I started skimming the book as (based on the blurbs) I anticipated the rest of the story (and I was correct). The ending was disappointingly predictable. Throughout, Kit’s ongoing passing as male is not believable, especially to have been able to serve in the air force for several years without suspicion or detection. Indeed, Kit requires another person’s identity to access these spaces in the first place, so is not being true to their own identity but putting on someone else’s. While this is a conscious decision by the author to grant Kit dignity and privacy, it belies the real logistical challenges Kit would have encountered; how Kit addresses those is essential to believing they can pass for so long and in environments like the military and larger urban centres. That the author wants to avoid this in favour of the magical realism of the story does not get past the reader’s questions about how it would work in the real world. It also seems that Kit is not embracing their identity or living honestly as non-binary, but rather doing what they can to pass in or hide from society without self-reflection or understanding. Granted, transparency would be difficult (to say the least) at that time, but they are not honest with themselves or their family either.

Ultimately, it felt like the author wanted to tell several stories at once – the magical realism of the selkie story brought into more modern times, the counterfactual of a non-binary person in the mid-century world, a love triangle in rural Ontario – and ultimately fails at all as none is complete. There are interesting stories here, they just don’t emerge from this messily written and poorly edited novel. A better novel in this vein is Curiosities.

Fate: little book library

7 – debut novel
11 – referral
25 – new author to me
33 – Canadian
34 – prize
38 – drivel

Leave a Reply

Powered by WordPress.com.

Up ↑